There are a lot of different ways to approach the questions of wedding ring etiquette. I can tell you the traditional rules, but I would like to add my own opinions and throw in some common sense ideas to help out modern men and women. We aren’t living in the 1800s.
Engagement Ring Etiquette: Cost
Men: If you are playing by traditional rules, you (or your family) must pay for the engagement ring. And, don't become a cheapskate. If everything goes according to plan, your future wife will be wearing that ring every day for the rest of her life. On the other hand, it is not uncommon for a woman to chip in so that she can have a ring that she really loves.
Ladies: Here are a few situations where I think it makes sense for you to cough up a contribution:
- Your man is divorced and a large chunk of his paycheck goes for child support.
- You are a cradle-robbing cougar. (Lucky girl.)
- You earn more than your boyfriend does.
- You want something better than your man can provide.
Engagement Ring Etiquette: How Much to Spend?
Men: The DeBeers diamond company suggests that you spend the equivalent of two months’ salary on a diamond ring. That’s an arbitrary amount and you don’t need to spend that much if you are unable. Remember that most decent jewelers will allow you to “trade up” for a larger stone, in a few years, when you are more established.
Should You Buy a Large Diamond?
Whether you like it or not, a woman’s status is sometimes appraised, as a first impression, by the size of her rock. Is this stupid? Yes. Does it really happen? Yes. In general, younger men spend less on a ring and older men spend more, however there are lots of exceptions to this rule.
Diamond Solitaire Engagement Rings
Most women prefer a diamond solitaire for an engagement ring, but there are no rules saying that you must blindly follow the DeBeers ad campaigns. Some women like other precious gems. And, just like some women wear colored wedding dresses, it’s perfectly acceptable to use a ruby, sapphire, emerald, black diamond, or whatever you want for your engagement ring.
My personal opinion is that if you wear a CZ wedding/engagement ring, you should plan on replacing it with a real gemstone (of any kind) in a few years, but it’s your call.
Must You Have an Engagement Ring?
Not every woman cares about getting an engagement ring. Some chicks want a plain wedding band or an eternity band. I would say that an eternity band with diamonds or gemstones would be a good substitute for an engagement solitaire, but I feel that wearing a plain gold band before the ceremony would be weird.
Should the Man Surprise His Girlfriend?
Men: I think it is very romantic for a boyfriend to get down on one knee and propose in Hollywood style. If you are going to pick out an engagement solitaire (on your own), you should make sure that the store will refund your money if you are refused or your sweetie wants a different ring. You can present your chickadee with a plain solitaire ring (Tiffany setting) and allow her to choose her own setting.
How to Wear an Engagement Ring
In North America, most women wear engagement rings on the fourth finger of their left hands. Before the wedding ceremony, a girl puts her engagement ring on her right hand so her husband can place her wedding ring on her left hand. After this, a woman has two choices:
- She can put her engagement ring back on her left hand while keeping the wedding ring closer to her heart. The engagement ring will be on the outside.
- She can keep wearing her engagement ring on her right hand forever.
In some European countries, the engagement ring is worn on the third finger of the right hand. However, there are lots of cultural and familial variations. You can wear your engagement ring however you want, but this is one time that you should consider family traditions.
Family Heirloom Ring
Men: You can give your girl a family ring but things could get sticky if the engagement is broken. Do consider this before presenting your sweetheart with granny’s five carat ring.
Who Gets the Engagement Ring?
If an engagement is broken, proper etiquette is for the girl to return the ring. On the other hand, each state has its own legal precedents. Some laws say that an engagement ring is a gift and the woman may keep it. Some laws say that an engagement ring is a conditional gift, which is something like a contract to marry. If the engagement is broken, the contract has not been carried out, and the woman must return the ring.
I am not a lawyer and the following circumstances are just my personal opinions:
- If the ring is a family heirloom, the girl must give it back.
- If the engagement is broken because the guy is a jerk (for example, he cheated with his fiancĂ©e’s best friend), I believe that she held up her end of the bargain and the woman should be allowed to keep the ring.
If the stone is valuable, you might need a lawyer to determine ownership. Engagement ring etiquette can vary by country, by state, by religion, and by family. I feel that a man should get his girl a great ring; however he should not go deeply into debt. With a beautiful setting, any diamond or gemstone will look fabulous.